A valid look at the 2009 Top Wines of the year should
include a combination of the results from both the Wine Spectator (WS) and Wine Enthusiast’s (WE)” Top 100 Wines of the Year”. What are the
trends? What are the top countries and producers? Is one of the publications
more biased towards Italy? Is one of the publications more focused on Pinot noirs?
Is the USA representation appropriate?
To make this analysis statistically more significant, the
two lists are pooled, and some interesting facts are revealed. What are the most inexpensive wines of the 2009
selected? What are the most expensive wines of 2009 selected? What are the emerging varietals and blends with significant “picks”?
About the Scores and Publications: Both highly
respected publications have their own scoring rules to include the raw quality
score, availability, price, and an “X” factor -excitement. Needless to say, some of the most scarce, expensive wines may not be included as selections even though their raw, judge’s score is very
high. Both publications’ headquarters
are in New York, USA.
GrapeStone Concepts
Conclusions:
Top Countries: It is not surprising to see the
top countries selected are the USA, France, Italy, Spain and Australia.
Top Varietals: It is not a shock to see that
the top varietals selected are Pinot Noir, Cabernet Sauvignon, Chardonnay,
Sangiovese (including Chianti) blends, and Shiraz and Syrah. But a surprising
number of selections are blends of the Châteauneuf-du-Pape
style of GSM’s (Grenache, Syrah, Mourvèdre, +others) from both old and new
world growing regions. And, the number of non-Chianti reds of Italy are quite
high. The number of both new and old world Tempranillo blends is significant. It
is wonderful to see the number of new and old world Rieslings and Sauvignon
blancs in the list. The “pure varietal” winner, however, is Pinot Noir.
Otherwise, Cabernet Sauvignon combined with the Bordeaux blends and other cab-based red blends would be the overwhelming
winner.
Top Regions: Some of the top regions include: Napa Valley (inclusive of internal AVA’s- 13
total), Tuscany (inclusive of internal regions - 14 selected), Australia’s
Barossa Valley (6 selected), Sonoma’s Russian River Valley and Sonoma Coast(13
combined), France’s Bordeaux (6 selected), Argentina’s Mendoza( 5 selected).
What is a revelation in this analysis? It is really remarkable to see the great
showing and good value of the Columbia Valley, Washington wines (12 selections).
Number of Wines $20 and under Since these two
lists were compiled with value and availability weighing against judges’
scores, it is still astonishing to see that there were 31 wines that are $20 or
less.
Email : maggie@grapestoneconcepts.com
and we will send you a document of the combined list of the Top 200 WS and WE wines that retail for $20 or less.
4 least expensive wines in the combined 2009 Top 200 Wine Spectator and
Wine Enthusiast:
|
Producer
|
Region
|
Wine
|
WE/WS Rank
|
Price
|
|
Barnard Griffin
|
Columbia Valley, WA
|
Riesling
|
66
|
$8
|
|
d’Arenberg
|
McLaren Vale, Australia
|
The Stump Jump Shiraz
|
82
|
$11
|
|
Allram
|
Kamptal, Austria
|
Qualitätswein Trocken Kamptal
Strassertaler
|
45
|
$12
|
|
Loosen Brothers
|
Mosel ,Germany
|
Riesling QbA
|
62
|
$12
|
4 most expensive wines in the combined 2009 Top 200 Wine
Spectator and Wine Enthusiast:
|
Producer
|
Region
|
Wine
|
WE/WS Rank
|
Price
|
|
Fontodi
|
Chianti Classico, Italy
|
Colli Della Tuscan Centrale Flaccianello
(Sangiovese)
|
8
|
$110
|
|
Close des Papes
|
Châteauneuf-du-Pape, France
|
Châteauneuf-du-Pape
|
42
|
$115
|
|
Château Ducru-Beaucaillou
|
St. Julien, Bordeaux, France
|
Bordeaux blend
|
96
|
$145
|
|
Bonneau du Martray
|
Burgundy, France
|
Corton-Charlemagne Grand Cru
|
98
|
$150
|
Producers picked by both publications:
There were only 3 producers selected by both Top 100 lists.
1. Bodega Centena Zapata (Argentina) for their 2005 &
2007 Malbec
2. Brancott’s (New Zealand) Sauvignon blanc
3. Two Hands (Australia) Shiraz - Bad Impersonator and Bell’s
Garden
Data: Combined results
of the Top 100 Wine Spectator and Wine Enthusiast 2009 selections
Most frequently
selected countries and varietals:
|
Country
|
# top wines
|
|
Argentina
|
6
|
|
Australia
|
14
|
|
Austria
|
5
|
|
Chile
|
5
|
|
France
|
31
|
|
Germany
|
5
|
|
Hungary
|
2
|
|
Italy
|
27
|
|
New Zealand
|
6
|
|
Portugal
|
4
|
|
South Africa
|
2
|
|
Spain
|
15
|
|
USA
|
78
|
|
Top Varietals
and Unique blends only
|
# Top Wines
|
|
Pinot Noir
|
18
|
|
Cabernet Sauvignon
|
17
|
|
Red Blends including Bordeaux with Cab
|
16
|
|
Chardonnay
|
16
|
|
Syrah*
|
13
|
|
Riesling
|
12
|
|
Shiraz*
|
11
|
|
Sangiovese Blends (including Chianti)
|
11
|
|
GSM+ Blends
|
11
|
|
Tempranillo Blends
|
7
|
|
Malbec
|
6
|
|
Nebbiolo
|
5
|
|
Sauvignon blanc
|
5
|
|
Pinot Gris/Grigio
|
4
|
|
Touriga National Blends
|
4
|
|
Zinfandel
|
4
|
|
* same grape, stylistically different
|
|
Readers: Your comments on these trends are valued.
Recent Comments